Week five

The fifth week of the hearing took place at the Council Chambers at Environment Southland from Monday 14 August until Thursday 17 August 2017. The Panel heard from a range of individual submitters including sheep and beef, dairy, and deer farmers, as well as organisations including the NZ Deer Farmers Association, Balance Agri-nutrients, the Fertiliser Association of NZ, Ravensdown and the Southland Conservation Board.

Schedule for Week Five

Schedule - Week Five

Hearing panel documents

Questions for Environment Southland's reporting officer about NPSFM and NES plantation forestry

Tabled evidence

​DateDocument​
Tabled by​Submitter number
11 AugustResponse to questions about use of physiographic zone maps
P Maw – Counsel for ES-
​14 August
Speaking notes​​Holder, W​381
​Presentation​NZDFA​609
​Revised chart from L Fung evidence
NZDFA609
Video (YouTube)
NZDFA609
NZDFA Landcare Manual
NZDFA609
​Map​Browning, Stuart​96
​Speaking notes
Smith, JR & DM​​419
15 AugustSpeaking notes​​Ruddenklau, I​696
​Speaking notes and photos
​Tulloch, Ian​83, 93, 775, 807
​Map​Smith, Barry​731
​Planting cost analysis
Smith, Barry731
​Cost analysis
Smith, Barry731
​Speaking notes
Baker, David
​40
​Hearing statement
​Watt, B​749
16 August
Presentation​Allan, Peter & Dianne​​15
Speaking notes
​Aratiatia Livestock​24
​Map​B D Farm Trust​32
​Speaking notes
​Tremaine Farming​822
​Presentation​Coasthaven & Paterson Gavara
​155
​Amended evidence
​Coasthaven & Paterson Gavara​155
​Map​Coasthaven & Paterson Gavara​155
​Speaking notes
​Coasthaven & Paterson Gavara​155
​Hearing statement
​Hunt, A​23, 70, 244, 318, 320, 413, 618, 632, 648, 649
​Waikawa River Restoration Plan
​Marshall, A & K​502
​Speaking notes
​Marshall, A & K​502
​Calculations​Marshall, S​507
​Speaking notes
​Menlove, W​561
​Nutrient calculations
​Swney, G & B​789
17 AugustConsent monitoring fees​​Christey, A​129
​Speaking notes
​Willans, M & T​871
​Maps​Anderson, T​21
​Speaking notes
​Horrell, P​389
​Speaking notes
​Rimu Grasslands666
​Written response to panel questions
​Kelly, C803

Audio files (MP3)

​14 August
15 August​16 August​17 August​
Hearing Chair and 148 – P and L ClementHearing Chair and 696 – I and J Ruddenklau​015 – P and D Allan​074 – G  and R Black
​355 – D Harris  ​101 – T Buckingham​460 – G Laidlaw129 – A Christey
​381 – W and T Holder​426 – A and R Johnston and start of Tulloch Group (083/093/775/807)​022 – Aparima Bridge Farm132 – D Church
​444 – H King​Tulloch Group representing  083 G Bosker, 093 – Broadacres Ltd, 775 – Stoney Creek Station Ltd and 807 – The Terraces Ltd​024 – Aratiatia Livestock Ltd871 – M and T Willans
​609 – R Cook for NZ Deer Farmers​731 – B Smith032 – B D Farm Trust021 – T Anderson
​609 -  L Fung for NZ Deer Farmers​489 - J and H MacDonald​822 – Tremaine Farming211 – D Ditchfield
609 – S Wright for NZ Deer Farmers040 – D Baker​155 – Coasthaven Farms and Paterson Gavara Trust224 – P Duffy
609 – A Cade for NZ Deer Farmers​778 – Strathallan Farms Ltd502 – A and K Marshall and  099 – G Buckingham389 – P Horrell
609 – A Cade for NZ Deer Farmers​394 – O and S Hudson​507 – S Marshall666 – Rimu Grasslands and Leicester Downs Ltd
739 – J Somerville​535 – T McKee and 532 – M and C McKee Partnership528 – A and D McKay324 – Glentui Farms
​805 – The Roading Co Ltd749 – W Watt for the Southland Conservation Board 561 – W Menlove604 – Nokomai Station Ltd
​858 – Westend Station​789 – G and B Swney133 – Civil Tech Ltd
​048 – Ballance Agri-nutrientsEnd of 789 and 246 – H English
803 – Fertiliser Association of NZFortuna group representing: 23 – Apolima Farms Ltd, 70 – Betapahu Farms Ltd, 244 – Elya Holdings Ltd, 318 – Glenarlea Farms Ltd, 320 – Gleneden Dairies Ltd, - 413 – Iron Bridge Farms Ltd, 618 – Onepu Farms Ltd, 632 – Peat View Dairies Ltd, 648 – Puke Rua Dairies Ltd and  649 – Puke Tahi Dairies Ltd.
​661 – Ravensdown Ltd​712 – Seaview Trust and Oraka Farms
Hearing Panel and 096 – S Browning​806 – Southern District Health Board
419 – J R and D M Smith Ltd​758 – Southwood Export, Kodansha and Plantation Forests (SWEL)

Page reviewed: 30 Aug 2017 11:29am