ES Catchment Management Division (APP-20211135)
Public notice is hereby given pursuant to S.95A of the Resource Management Act 1991 that the following application for resource consent has been received by Environment Southland.
A hearing was held at 9:00 am on 30 August 2024 at Environment Southland, Cnr North Rd & Price St, Invercargill.
The application [reference APP-20211135] is for the following resource consents to authorise the following activities at Titiroa tide gates, adjacent to Middleton Road South, Fortrose:
- Occupy part of the coastal marine area with a tidegate structure
- Occupy part of the coastal marine area with a weir structure
- Dam and divert water
The tidegates operate by opening when there is positive downstream flow and shutting when tidal flow reverses. The purpose is to prevent high tides from raising water level beyond the gates, which would inundate a wider area. The tidegates are part of the wider Mataura Catchment Control Scheme designed to reduce flood damage of land.
Purpose: Flood effect mitigation
Location: Titiroa tidegates, Titiroa River, about 185 metres upstream of the Tokanui Gorge Road Highway Bridge. The tidegates are sited at about NZTM2000 1,276,640 E 4,836,895 N
Legal Description of Property: Section 1 SO 11258, Part Lot 1 DP 11173, Road Reserve and Riverbed.
Address for Service: Luke McSoriley, WSP, P O Box 647, Invercargill 9810
Full details of this application are also available for inspection at Environment Southland, corner of Price Street and North Road, Waikiwi, Invercargill during working hours (8.00 am to 5.00 pm).
Submissions on the above application must be received by Environment Southland no later than 5 pm 11 September 2023. A submission form is available below and you may also download a printable submission form and forward the completed form by email to service@es.govt.nz or esconsents@es.govt.nz
Any person may make a submission on the application, but a person who is a trade competitor of the applicant may do so only if that person is directly affected by an effect of the activity to which the application relates that:
(a) adversely affects the environment; and
(b) does not relate to trade competition or the effects of trade competition.
Submissions must be dated and signed (unless submitted electronically) and must include the following information:
- your name, postal address and telephone number (and fax number if applicable);
- details of the application in respect of which you are making the submission;
- whether it is in support of, or in opposition to the application, or is neutral;
- your submissions, with reasons;
- the decision that you wish Council to make; and
- whether you wish to be heard in support of your submission
and you must also serve a copy of your submission on the applicant as soon as reasonably practicable.
s95-95G Notification Document
Submissions
- Submission - Department of Conservation - APP-20211135.pdf (PDF, 203.5KB)
- Submission - Fish & Game New Zealand - Southland Region - APP-20211135.pdf (PDF, 2.1MB)
- Submission - Frisby, Les - APP-20211135.pdf (PDF, 2.6MB)
- Submission - Golden, Philip & Leigh - APP-20211135.pdf (PDF, 253.3KB)
- Submission - Holms, Alexander - APP-20211135.pdf (PDF, 1.2MB)
- Submission - Morton, Kerry - APP-20211135.pdf (PDF, 237.8KB)
- Submission - Roger McNaughton on behalf of Southland Recreational Whitebaiters Assn (PDF, 1.4MB)
- Submission - Te Ao Marama Inc. on behalf of Ngā Rūnanga - APP-20211135.pdf (PDF, 539.3KB)
s42a Council Hearing Report and Appendices
Pre-Circulation Applicant Evidence
- 01 Statement of Applicant's Evidence - Leslie Frisby.pdf (PDF, 1.2MB)
- 02 Statement of Applicant's Evidence - David Connor - Team Leader Catchment Operations at Southland Regional Council (PDF, 1.1MB)
- 02A APPENDIX 1 - David Connor Evidence.pdf (PDF, 11MB)
- 03 Statement of Applicant's Evidence - Laura Drummond - Principal Scientist at Instream Consulting (PDF, 2MB)
- 04 Statement of Applicant's Evidence - Luke McSoriley - Technical Principal - Planning at WSP New Zealand Limited (PDF, 319.6KB)
- 05 Statement of Applicant's Evidence - Colin Young.pdf (PDF, 262.1KB)
- 06 Statement of Applicant's evidence - Matthew Gardner - Consulting Engineer at Land River Sea Consulting Limited (PDF, 3.4MB)
Pre-Circulation Submitter Expert Evidence
- Statement of Submitter Evidence - Alan Christie - DOC.pdf (PDF, 215.8KB)
- Statement of Submitter Evidence - Ashiley Sycamore - DOC.pdf (PDF, 220.8KB)
- Statement of Submitter Evidence - Dean Whaanga and Stevie-Rae Blair - Awarua.pdf (PDF, 492.7KB)
- Statement of Submitter Evidence - Jane Bowen - DOC.pdf (PDF, 1.5MB)
- Statement of Submitter Evidence - Margaret Agnes Ferguson - Awarua.pdf (PDF, 425KB)
Applicant Hearing Evidence
- Legal submissions - ES Catchment Management Division - Chris Thomsen 29 Aug 2024.pdf (PDF, 324.6KB)
- Summary of Applicant Evidence - Colin Young.pdf (PDF, 83.8KB)
- Summary of Applicant Evidence - Dave Connor.pdf (PDF, 104.8KB)
- Summary of Applicant Evidence - Laura Drummond rebuttal.pdf (PDF, 257.4KB)
- Summary of Applicant Evidence - Luke McSoriley.pdf (PDF, 258.2KB)
- Summary of Applicant Evidence - Matthew Gardner.pdf (PDF, 95.1KB)
- Summary of Evidence - Leslie Frisby.pdf (PDF, 84.4KB)
Minutes and post hearing
- 01 - Minute 1 - ES Catchment Management Division - 6 September 2024 (PDF, 125.3KB)
- 02 - Memorandum of counsel for applicant regarding directions and responses in writing to amended proposal (PDF, 76.8KB)
- 03 - Minute 2 - ES Catchment Management Division - 17 September 2024 (PDF, 128KB)
- 04 - CPT-608464-1-473-1 Memorandum of counsel for the applicant in response to questions from Commissioner 8102024 (PDF, 20.5KB)
- 04A - CPT-608464-1-479-1 Gardner Memo response to Commissioner questions (PDF, 604.1KB)
- 04B - CPT-608464-1-480-1 Memo Drummond in response to September Questions (PDF, 88.7KB)
- 05 - Response from Te Ao Marama Inc 22 Oct 2024 - APP-20211135 (PDF, 121KB)
- 05 - Response from the Director-General of Conservation 22 Oct 2024 - APP-20211135 (PDF, 196.5KB)
- 06 - Fourth Memorandum of Counsel for the Applicant APP-20211135 (PDF, 828.1KB)
- 07 - Minute 3 - ES Catchment Operations Division - 24 October 2024 (PDF, 139.8KB)
- 08 - Joint Memorandam of Counsel concerning s42A officer participation in expert conferencing (PDF, 131.3KB)
- 09 - LB-608464-1-565-1 Joint Witness Statement expert ecology conferencing (PDF, 197.3KB)
- 09A - Final Signed November 13 Titiroa Tide Gates RCA APP-20211135 JWS Planning (PDF, 487.7KB)
- 10 - MC-608464-1-595-1 Memorandum of Counsel for the Applicant 15112024 (PDF, 71.6KB)
- 11 - Minute 4 - ES Catchment Operations Division - 18 November 2024 (PDF, 126.5KB)
- 12 - s42A reporting officer comments APP-20211135 (PDF, 294.6KB)